Discusses topics
Prof.
Tushar Chavan, Rashtriya Jr.College,
Chalisgaon
Dist. Jalgaon
1)
Is there any need of A, B, C, D activity sheet sets for English in the coming
HSC board exam?
2)
Oral exam should be removed or not from the evaluation of Std. XI and XII.
All
are requested to share your views freely on these topics.
Jr.
College English Teachers’ Group 1
Prof.D.G.Patil
Sir, I think there shouldn't be need of A, B, C, D pattern
of activity sheet and also oral shouldn't be removed.
Prof.Kiran
Kulkarni
I think there is no need of A,B,C,D sets in English
and Oral Exam shouldn't be there. 100 marks Question Paper should be there in
board exam for English.
Prof.
Vlias Borse
We don't need ABCD sets but ORAL EXAM should be there.
Our students speak Marathi or Hindi in their day - today life but they don't
have that much scope to speak English. If authority continues oral for our
students, they will practice speaking & motivated to speak elsewhere.
Prof.D.G.Patil
They have stopped ABCD sets & no oral exam will be
there for SSC. I think they will continue the same pattern. But it's an
injustice with the subject like English. As a foreign language we should have
this tool to evaluate the speaking skill of our students.
Prof.Dr.Ganesh
Agarwal
I have a doubt about all this... if you are looking 4
student's benefits then giving 20 marks under oral exam is useless... what do have
analyze in speaking skill? Here people are only talking about 5 % students who
can read and speak in English? Majority of d students from Maharashtra are from
Rural Area. Think about it. Actually evaluation must be on detail study of the
course book. MCQ based... and old pattern....
Prof.
Prashant Bagul
There is no need of A B C D activity sets because it’s
very difficult to maintain same difficulty level for these four sets. Oral Exam
is need of this age. It is through this tool we can judge communicative skill
of our students.
Prof.Kale
Madam
Sir, I think
oral exams are necessary. The change should be come from 1st std. not 10th.11th
std. student is unable to make proper construction & expression in English.
Oral is support material. Its impact on results. ABCD activity sheet are useful
for prohibited copy in the class. We should give oral marks as per talent of
student.
Prof.Sanjay
Jadhav
I think there is no need of ABCD Sets as it is
activity sheet. In new pattern, Oral exam must be compulsory but instead of
marks, Grades like A B C D should be given. Minimum C grade should be obtained
in English to pass the Exam.
Prof.Kailas
Patil, Chopada
I think that there is no need a set ABCD because now
questions are based on activities about oral test, it’s must, teacher can test
student's knowledge about skill of language.
Jr.
College English Teachers’ Group 2
Prof.Sunil
Bhamre
If we consider this curriculum as skill based then for
the evaluations of four skills Oral Test is necessary.
Prof.Sajjad
Ahmad Khan, Patur, Akola
A B C D pattern will be excluded from FEB 2019 for
HSC.
No Oral exam from 2020 for std. 11 and 2021for std.
12.
New text book of Std.11 Based on Activity based format
will be launched from 2019- 20
Prof.Mansoor
Sir
In my opinion there is no need of A B C D pattern for
only English subject as per new pattern as it is stressing to students and
whole system of HSC exam. Make it simple stress free.
Oral exam is essential to judge the language Skills.
Prof.Bhadane
Sir, Nimgaon Malegaon
Oral exam should continue, useful for students. ABCD
pattern has not needed.
I really have a strong objection for this A,B,C,D
pattern. Why did the board introduce it for ONLY ENGLISH?
If copy cases was the reason, then what about other
languages and subjects? Subjects like Economics, S.P., OC and Geography etc.,
there are objective questions which hardly require last 5 to 10 mins for students to copy/ cross
check and all. Mostly students never write the answers of these objective
questions in the beginning although they fall in the first 3 questions in the
question papers. Why only in English we teachers follow that A,B,C,D pattern?
Even in assessments and moderation we follow strictly
the rules like bifurcation of marks and minimizing of marks? Isn't it a kind of
injustice to students and teachers too. I myself had watched the people of
other subjects and even languages allotting and moderating marks without
bifurcation.
As far as orals ate concerned, they are a must. But
there is also injustice to students. In the classes of orals, we strictly allot
marks based on the skills of the innocent students who are present with at
least some preparation. What happens to us when we assess the orals of the
students who appear in the last days of record submissions? Do we check their
abilities thoroughly? What about those students who appear in the July board
exams? Are we so serious at that time too? Is this the way are we just to all?
Prof.
Vijay Pawar, Vile Parle, Mumbai
I can understand that there should not be copy case
anywhere. But if I go through the writing skills of other boards like Nashik,
Amaravati etc., the students hardly can read and write properly. Still getting
decent marks in all subjects including English. But when it comes to Mumbai
board, every CM and Moderator, including me, becomes strict for rules. As if
they had the power to bend the juniors.
Copying in
examinations must be eradicated. But thoroughly including all subjects and all
boards plus all over the country.
To cite an example, one of my students from Bihar had
started her education from std. XI Commerce. She did neither go to school nor
did she attempt any board paper till Std. X th passing with 73%.
It's the fact.
Prof.
Gulhane
I feel strongly that there is no need of ABCD sets. Better
that would have excluded till now. Let’s oppose it in large number. Orals and
project work be continued.
Jr.
College English Teachers’ Group 3
Prof.Pravin
Rode
There should be A B C D activity sheet. It will create
difficulty level for the students. It will even make them more meticulous.
Oral exam
should not be there. The very purpose of the exam is exiled. It does not help
students.
Prof.Satish
Bhonde
Oral exam should be removed.
Prof.Sachin
Hawaldar
I feel the same about A B C D activity sheets but oral
exams should be there. It helps students to develop L S R W skills. It is the
basic of any language. Its implementation should be somewhat like science practical.
There should be external examiner. All of we should take it seriously while we
are conducting oral exams. Thats all ....
Prof.S.S.Shaikh
1. There must be ABCD.
2. Activity is nothing but the Captcha system so there
must be some weightage for descriptive answers other than writing skill.
3. Oral must be there but with external examiner.
4. Textbook must be small and should consist of
literary content.
Prof.Ramdas
Nikam
I think there is no need of A B C D activity sheet as
it makes a kind of segregation. Only one activity sheet is sufficient as there
is only one question paper in other subjects. Why then ABCD in English subject
only? It's injustice to the subject. And oral exam is must for the development
of language skills.
Prof.Sanju
Pardeshi, Chembur, Mumbai
I don't think that there is any requirement of ABCD,
because it was implemented with the intention of preventing mass copy. But now
with Activity Sheet as it’s based on creativity.
So far oral exam is concert it should be there as it
develops the skills of students.
It is the responsibility of all teachers to conduct
the oral exam honestly.
We can have External examiner for the same to have the
seriousness in it.
Prof.Krunal
Sir, Nagpur
There is no need of ABCD activity sheets it was there
to prevent cheating in exams but it has made no difference being a teacher of
Ashram School it should be there because it decreases the difficulty level of
foreign language rural area students are less confident in solving English
paper so oral exam should be there they can't even right 80 marks question
paper how can we expect from them to write 100 marks of question paper it
should be there.
Prof.Ganesh
Lohe
I agree with you sir. (Agree with Prof.Ramdas Nikam’s
views)
Prof.Triveni
Madam
Agree with you sir. (Agree with Prof.Ramdas Nikam’s
views)
Prof.Deepak
Shedage
There is no need of A, B, C, D activity sheets.
For science subject practical is necessary.
So for Language subject, Oral exam must be necessary.
External examiner should take oral exam.
Prof.Suryawanshi
Sir
I also agree with you sir. (Agree with
Prof.Ramdas Nikam’s views)
Prof.
A.R.Pawar
I also agree with you sir. (Agree with Prof.Krunal’s
views)
Prof.Shimpi
Pravin, Somayya Mumbai
I do agree.
There is certainly no need of ABCD because present pattern is based on
creativity as there are activity based questions to solve them students have to
use their own skill and knowledge so ABCD should not be there but oral should
be there to help students to develop skill of LSRW. But it should be conducted
honestly.
Prof.Sanju
Bhau
No need of ABCD, but oral should be necessary
Jr.
College English Teachers’ Group 4
D.S.Patil
Sir, MHSK. Kolhapur
Dear Sir,
I think, to avoid mass copy, there must be a code
system. But while setting papers according to code system, proper weightage
must be given to all papers.
Regarding oral exam, I think, there are many
controversies. But as far as other subjects concerned viz. science, there must
be parallel system to the practical exams. Because, in practical exams also,
students get out of marks.so impartial system should be implemented regarding
the oral exam. After all in every system, there are drawbacks. We have to
forward the system without any fault..........
Prof.
Shirsath D. Y. C. D. Jain College of Commerce,
Shrirampur (A.nagar)
1) Now H.S.C.is only a qualified level for Graduating,
so we mustn't provide ABCD code.
2) Oral exam is big farce today.. Teacher puts out of
marks to Even dull student.
So remove as early as possible.
Stop all these malpractices. Please maintain quality
based one activity sheet.
Prof.C.M.Gaikwad
Oral exam is good to test listening and speaking
skills. Do we really and honestly conduct this? Do we really follow the format
given by the Board? The answer is no. That’s why the Board is thinking of
saying goodbye to oral exams.
Prof.Ishrat
Khan
As per my concern oral exams should be there as it's
only the way to judge the base of English language skills that is L,S,W,R
and next question of giving marks to the
dull students that depends on teachers tact she should be genuine as she or he
is a role model for upcoming generation.
Prof.Sudam
Deshmukh, Pimpalgaon BK
I think before giving some suggestions regarding these
both issues, it will be better to see why they are initiated.
1) A B C D Sets r initiated to stop mass copy, yes and
it works very well so far, student afraid to do that. But now activity sheets are
presented before them which require more time to solve out with better
performance so I think sets pattern should be removed because activity sheet
itself helps to stop mass copy.
2) Oral exams must be remained as usual .Oral exam has
been initiated to evaluate student's skill not memory.
It is up to us (teacher / organizer) how to handle it.
Whatever it is blamed (That teacher becomes too liberal for giving marks) is a
fault of conductor /organizer not of a system, so oral exams r good to evaluate
students internal skills and must be retained as it is.
Prof.Sajjad
Ahmad Khan, Patur, Akola
The decision had already taken about No A B C D sets
from coming session and No oral from next session. What we have to do now?
Prof.Kerkal
Madam
Is it true no ABCD sets from Feb 2019?
Prof.Sajjad
Ahmad Khan, Patur, Akola
Yes 100%. There is no need of ABCD papers after
Activity sheet because we have to face varied or multiple answer for each
activity. Officially I knew 3 board of studies members while talking them in
our Delta's meeting on it. In December or coming month there will be a
notification on it will be published in Shikshan Sankraman.
Jr.
College English Teachers’ Group 5
Prof.Shyam
Jagtap, Kopargaon
I think there's no need of set code activity sheet because
proper evaluation will not possible. Second thing about oral it must be there because
it is useful enhance oral communication but from initial stage strict
implementation must be there
Prof.Smita
Warpe
The basic objection is malpractices so the board
introduced sets. If we can curb it things will be fair.
As far as orals are concerned it is in hands of
teachers and management to make them more authentic by establishing
credibility.
Prof.Shyam
Jagtap, Kopargaon
To,
Prof.Smita Warpe
Mam malpractices only in English? Unbelievable!
Follow d system for all languages, if possible.
Prof.Smita
Warpe
To,
Prof.Shyam Jagtap
No. Have I said it? But it is compulsory subject so
the number of copy cases obviously is big.
Prof.
Santosh Dorake
1) I think that there should not be any difference
between English and other languages in terms of evaluation. So there is no need
to set A, B, C, D sets of question papers for only English subject.
They were introduced to avoid malpractices in the
board exam. We can do it by using other ways.
2) Oral exams
are still necessary to check the communication skills of the students; I would
suggest that oral should be of 30 marks.
Prof.Vaishali
Jane
Respected Sir, I think there is no need of A,B,C,D
activity sheet sets for English. It is unjust for English. Already, most of the
students are afraid of English subject. So, there should be one question paper
like other subjects.
Oral exam
should not be removed from the evaluation because it helps to develop various
skills in students as well as helps the weak students to pass the exam .If it
is removed, it will be also unjust for our subject (English) because other
subjects have projects or practicals which help students to pass or to increase
their percentage. So, equal evaluation pattern should be there for all
subjects.
Prof.Kalpesh
Patil
Respected Tushar sir,
I think there must not be sets. Because others subject
doesn't have that kind of format so why should be for English. More over more
than 53 marks are common in all sets. Only it differs 23 marks. And about oral
evaluation it must be followed because it develops basic skill of learning
language that is LSRC...
Prof.Noorjahan
I also agree sir with u. (Agree with Prof.Kalpesh
Patil’s views)
Prof.Sagarika
Chatopadhya
I completely agree with you regarding the A,B,C,D Sets
particularly in the new Paper Pattern.
Oral exam is a necessity for many students, but it
also creates a lot of discrepancies in the scoring, as examiners and moderators
we all have experienced that, like a student scoring anything between 20and
30out of 80, scored 20/20. Our commitment needs to be fair as well.
As far as I know, the projects for all other subjects
also are not going to be there as well.
Prof.Smita
Warpe
I am in favour of oral exams but I am sharing with the
group objections raised during discussion and we couldn’t argue there.
Prof.Shivaji
Thakur
I am not favour of oral exam.
Prof.Burle
Sir, (Agree with Prof.Santosh
Dorake’s views)
Prof.Gitanjali
Divekar, (Agree with Prof.Santosh
Dorake’s views)
Prof.Deepali
Bhagwat, (Agree with Prof.Santosh
Dorake’s views)
Prof.Rajesh
Agarwal
If oral exam is necessary then marks must be allotted
according to the ratio of written. In this case nobody will recommend oral!
Prof.
Santosh Dorake
To,
Prof.Rajesh Agarwal
How is it possible?
Some students can perform well in oral test and some
can perform better in written test.
Prof.Amin
Sagar, (Agree with Prof.Vaishali Jane’s views)
Prof.Vaishali
Jane
We can only
give marks according to their responses in various skills. But we all know how
we give twenty marks to our students which are in our hands. We are in the same
boat excluding some exceptions. We have to increase our result and the Board
also wants the same. When I give 20 marks to all students who are eligible for
it or not, I feel guilty. Some students can write and some can answer orally
but commit mistakes in writing. So, we can't judge the students’ performances
on seeing one side.
Prof.Jagdale
Sir Khandgaon
Right (Agree with Prof.Vaishali Jane’s views)
Jr.
College English Teachers’ Group 6
Prof. N.J.Patil, N.A.Shinde Jr college Uchat, Wada
HSC board exam definitely needs ABCD activity sheet
sets as it will be now easy to copy each other’s sets if board follows only one
sheet for all students. Students should think and solve activity sheet on their
own.
Prof.Teresa George NMCDr.B.R.Ambedkar HS & Jr.college.Nagpur
Oral exam should not be removed. Some credit should be
given to oral (speaking/reading skill), besides these marks help the students
to pass the exam.
Prof. K L Suryawanshi Lakhani Bhandara
Having oral exam...it has been experienced that the
real credit is not given to the students who deserve the real potential...many
times these marks are given only to pass...so this is my personal opinion that
the oral examination should be excluded.
Oral examination has made a real injustice to
brilliant and intelligent...hard working students...and this is my own personal
experience...
Prof. Tonde Sir
Sir, I think so far as 12 board exam is concerned ABCD
set should be there but orals can be reduced.
Prof.C.J.Patil
Sirji
1) All the boards except ssc n hsc have their orals
then why should there be Injustice with our students
2) Why should there be four sets of Q papers for our
subject only why not for Physics n Maths
3) It means
only injustice with our students n English teachers.
Prof.Shevale
(Deore) Leena
I honestly feel that there is no need of sets because
the question paper already contends sub questions with many activities (
headache to solve and to check even) so framing sets is just a waste of time
money and teacher's energy how tough it is to check all the sets e.g terminal
exam papers.
Oral exam
should be there because it helps to increase the result of English so it must
be there for only English.
Prof.Birajdar
Sir, The model Multipurpose High school and Jr. College Malinagar
Why should English only have 4 sets?
About oral. What's happening with Science practicals? After
all the results of HSC AND SSC depend on the results of English subject.
Prof. Sachin V. Pawar Saphale, Palghar
True fact (Agree with Prof.Birajdar’s views)
It's good that English has A,B,C,D sheets but if we
think about overall then that activity should be students oriented for getting
marks, but only English subject has a,b,c,d sheets , sometimes it's like that
we do injustice with the students. If we
saw other subject especially science field those subjects have practical , but
we know very well that rural students face the problems of English so we must
think that there is only one question paper like other subjects, why should we
make students to become a victim of system. It's too shameful why should we
always injustice with students. Syllabus must have the skills like only to
improve LSRW (specially student learn to speak and read English without any
fear)
Prof. Sagar Bobade Sir Amaravati
What is the reason behind A.B.C.D. paper set?
What does the board want to prove from it?
So it's not necessary A,B,C,D sets.
Prof. Veena Kale
I agree with the view that there is no need of A,B,C,D
sets
Prof. Vaishali Badhe
A, B, C, D set
are not important. But oral examinations should be continued.
Prof.Sachin
Korde
We are too intelligent!!
What do you think about practicals of science faculty?
And other boards exam eg, CBSC or other!
That's not injustice? Horrible!
Prof.Nahate
Sir Sirsoli
A, B, C, D set are not important. But oral examinations
should be continued.
Prof.Sachin
Korde
Very true!
Only HSC board exam and only English subject
definitely needs ABCD activity sheet sets! There is no need of such pattern for
other subjects! Students who appear for other subjects never try to copy each
other!!!
Prof. Pachegaonkar G S, Latur
Yes it is right (Agree with Prof.Sachin Korde’s views)
Prof. Kailas Dusane
A B C D pattern will be excluded from FEB 2019 for
HSC.
No Oral exam from 2020 for std. 11 and 2021 for std.
12. New text book of Std. 11 Based on Activity based format will be launched
from 2019 - 20
Jr.
College English Teachers’ Group 7
Prof. Niraj Boharpi
Sir..... A B CD
sets are necessary but not necessary oral. At the same time in Xl & Xll syllabus
board must include the literature work of Shakespeare, Keats, R. Browning, John
Milton etc..
Prof.Biradar
Keshav,Mahatma Basweshwar college, Latur.
There is no
need of multi set question papers in the forthcoming HSC exam and oral exam is
not necessary.
Prof. Gurme
Nagnath Machindra (Shri. Shivaji Jr. College Latur)
Sr.....These
sets are very important nowadays because of the students think different way to
present their ideas. Students are able to think freely. This method is highly
creativity in writing skill. Oral method is very important in educational
system.
Prof. Laxman Caude
There is no
need of A, B, C, D because the student feels it’s as injustice. They judge on
their own level that particular set was easy and other particular set was
difficult. There is no set code for other subjects than why it is only for
English.
As about Oral concern, it is important and useful but
it is not been followed by the teachers. That's why it is become useless. So
oral should be remove from the syllabus and instead of it there must be include
easy portion as language study like 10th.
Prof. Jagjit Kaur Madam
A, B, C, D set
are not important. But oral examinations should be continued.
Prof.D.M.Neer,
Loksewa jr college kosamtondi. Dist- Gondia-
(Agree with Prof Jagjit Kaur Madam’s views)
Prof.Ajay
Mankawade- (Agree with Prof Laxman
Caude’s views)
Prof.
D.M.Labade, Abasaheb Kakade Jr College
Shevgaon
Dist. Ahmednagar
1. Obviously
there must be multi set question papers in the forthcoming HSC exam.
2. Oral exam is not at all necessary.
Prof.Sachin
Raut
A B C D sets must be there.
Prof. Dhanraj Mankare Sir
A, B, C, D sets
n oral exam, both should be there.
Prof.Raju
sir
No need of four sets
No need of oral
test
Prof. Shivani Pednekar
I think oral exam is necessary. Objectives of
languages such as speaking, reading, listening can be judged by oral skill.
Students can understand the importance of speaking which will be beneficial for
them in future and it will boost their confidence to face interviews. If CBSE
board students get oral marks then why not ours? There should be one system
about it in the country. Our students should not only be examinee they should
develop taste for language. And it will be possible if we give them chance to
express& explore. We should bring our students out from textbook prison.
There should be A,B,C,D sets. Students will
understand the importance of exam & will be aware about the least chance of
copy write.
Prof.D.M.Labade, Abasaheb
Kakade Jr. College,
Shevgaon
Dist. Ahmednagar
Basically these four skills, though we teach are not
mastered by students and vaguely no.of teachers allot 20 out of 20, Even they
can't speak single word in oral exam. Is it right? If there is oral exam then it should be
conducted by external teachers not by internal subject teachers. As we do not
credit the students properly, teachers discriminate. Otherwise there should not
be oral exam
Prof. Sujata Avachar
I agree oral
exams should be conducted by externals and also properly then and then the
motive can be achieved
Prof. Shivani Pednekar
We can make changes in it If the teacher gave 20 marks and the student got 40 out of 80 then his
oral marks would be depreciated in that
proportion, as we had that system in
University. And most important we cannot blame our teachers for giving
20 marks they think if everyone give why not me? What about CBSE teachers? Are they really
fair while giving marks? External examiner will do the same as we see it in
Science subjects. If a student passed in a 12 th board exam he gets opportunity
to give various exams to get employment. And can continue his education. Some
students will be thrown away from education if they failed frequently in
English in 12 th Education should open
the door to bright future and should not lock it .If you are weak in one
subject....it doesn't mean you are dull.
English is a real challenge for some rural students but real talent is
also hidden in them.
Prof.Azar
Aatif- (Agree with Prof Shivani
Pednekar’s views)
Prof. Laxman Caude
It's rare to possible, what's the value of oral if we
depreciate in the proportion as University as well CBSE
Prof.Shraddha
Misar
Oral is useful but it is not properly conducted nor
wisely judged. Students expect 20marks though they don't deserve. Even we
teachers offer liberal marks or our system compels us to do so. If we don't
give them full marks they make propaganda and don't take admissions in our
college. It’s a vicious circle. They know they will get min 15. They are not serious
regarding studies. Oral is best but system has corrupted it.
Prof.Ajay
Karande
Oral should conduct by external with properly on their
parameters; it can be helpful to students.
Prof.Shraddha
Misar
Activity sheet has potential to restrict copy by
students .Even books and guides are provided to students, they fail to copy out
from the materials. So A B C D are not required. Format of activity sheet makes
them to learn with understanding.
Prof. Laxman Caude
There is external for eve, what is use of it. Every
students are getting more than 40 marks out of 50?
Prof.Shraddha
Misar
It’s my earnest request to all that we should focus on
improving understanding of students and motivate them for enriching vocabulary
which is the major part in comprehension.
Prof.S.T.Dupare,
Jr.College Kavathi, (Agree with Prof
Shivani Pednekar’s views)
Prof.Sajid
N.Khan, Jr. College Sewli, (Agree
with Prof Shivani Pednekar’s views)
Prof.Shashi
Bari, St.Marys Jr.College, (Agree
with Prof Shivani Pednekar’s views)
Prof.Seema
Dandekar, Murud Janjira
Yes, sets and oral exam both necessary for rural areas
students.
Prof.Sudhakar
Kirmire
As a teacher from tribal area I think oral is
necessary. It helps the students to score passing marks in Eng. But if oral
exam will be conducted by external examiner not a single student from my college
would be able to score even 10/15 marks.
Prof.Gagare
Sir
Oral exam (20 marks) And written exam (80 makes) is
not part of discussion in today's situation instead of it is adjustment for
rural areas as well as to grip the lower and poor candidates due to not
basically language foundation.
Prof.U.S.Patil,
Kolhapur
No need of Oral exam and sets.
25 will be necessary and students will learn more
themselves now there is no fear of fail so they don't study.
I welcome new format.
Prof.Manisha
Chande
Oral is important for my rural students.
Prof.Guntaji
Oral exam is good for the students. They learn or try
to speak in English.
Prof.Raju
Sir
No need of four sets
Because
1) In four sets, while setting the question
paper, the difficulty level is not
properly maintained.
2) Students think that they would have scored more
marks if they had got rest of the sets.
3) It is revealed that some sets are easier for the
students to solve than other sets.
4) I have come to know that some of the grammar topics
are given more importance in some sets whereas they are neglected in other sets
and it is injustice.
So instead of 4 sets
We must have only one set to all the students so that
candidates may be evaluated accurately.
Oral tests must be cancelled because
1) The students who don't deserve 5 marks are
generously offered 20 out of 20
2) Due to oral test marks Most of the students are not
serious about their studies.
3) Not only the society but also the students are
making fun of the exam system.
4) If oral exam is cancelled, students will take their
studies seriously.
5) Due to oral exam more quantity and less quality is
being seen in schools and colleges.
6) Those who pass the exam with the help of oral marks
are good for nothing in further education.
So oral tests must be cancelled and I am sure they
will be cancelled.
Prof
Dhanraj Mankare Sir
There are few colleges which are not fulfilled with
basic needs like water n electricity.
There is no suitable environment for studies. Not even
their family earns enough money; hence they are unable to cope up with the
studies.
If they are not provided with such basic needs, they
should get oral marks, which encourage them to prepare for written exam.
Hence there should be oral exam.
Prof
Santosh Asabe Sir
I respect
the views expressed
by our colleagues that oral
tests are unnecessary. They simply
think these are
malpractices on the part
of teachers as well as students. But what we
see in current situation in fields
of Politics Commerce &
whatever the fields we think of. Don’t we
see such practices everywhere? What could
we do even our daily life & our service area. Especially injustice done to
us by the management of our college. I think frankly some of our students may
get benefits of marks of Oral exam. But
bye getting though such
exam They may
have career in so
called substandard areas in service based professions
& industries. Our society doesn't need only
scientists doctors & engineers
But it
also needs semiskilled persons ever
than before. So I think
a student who might have passed
just with the help of oral exam & proved his mettle in
future must not be underestimated....So these
exams are beneficial.. If you all
don't mind. Let me ask one question...
What about marks allotted to science students for practical exam. Do all the
students deserve the marks they get?
Prof
Santosh Asabe Sir
Pl just think
about the colleges
who have poor
feeding of students who belong to
their first generation of educational system especially students at Ashramshalas. How can they interact
in correct English at time of oral exam to get more marks?
Prof.Umakant
Mamile, Jr Narkhede
If look at the
admissions process less mark obtained student are taking admissions to science
faculty because they will think they will pass with the help of practical
marks. Those subjects’ teachers never think about cancelling the practical
work. If students ask do you like to take English subject if it is optional
subject, they say no. so think first of all about our subject and think about
it. So if we want to attract to students towards our subject, it is must. Some
students are from rural areas and poor families who do not attend the school they
will pass with the help of oral test. They never compete with the clever
student. Some think oral marks are given without assessment. Marks are given to
all. Clever pupil thinks, they will get marks but not complete with them. The
cbse students get chance of attending the oral test. They get the good credit
of oral marks. So the oral test remains as it is. I think.
Jr.
College English Teachers’ Group 8
Prof.
Bhushan Ishwar Birari Patonda Amalner
Really there is no need of A B C D pattern question
papers.
Orals should be removed from English. We all know that
how orals are conducted in schools. I know that It would not accept by all but
think over it that which generation is molded by us.
QP patter should be of 100 marks.
It should be based on activities.
Most important copy should be debarred from exams. For
this our teachers should change their mentality.
Like Tushar sir we all should be creative and should
prepare activity videos and provide students audio video teachings do students
would get interest in learning.
Prof.Swati
Jadhav, Karad
Some students are so weak that they can’t gain
35marks, for their sake oral should be there. Subjects like physics, Chemistry,
Biology passing become easy due to practical's 30marks. Most of the students
neglect languages, they focus on their group subjects .according to me, oral
should be there.
Prof.Bhushan
Ishwar Birari Patonda Amalner
Only passing
should not be considered. If so ....
Prof.Swati
Jadhav, Karad
Talented students won’t have any problem but weak students’
can’t get 35 marks. Some of them are unable to read properly, some can’t write
correct spelling of their own name.
Prof
Mangesh Mekhle Latur
Correct (Agree with Prof.Swati Jadhav’s views)
Prof.Deepak
Sir
We will get
only 30% result to art faculty oral exam help them to get 35 marks so orals are
very important.
Prof.Vilas
Bhopi
You ll have to conduct a new repeater batch in July
2019.
Prof.R.S.Kagane
H J P college Himayatnagar Dist Nanded
What step
should we all take to cancel ABCD sets? It's essential sir.
Prof.Vilas
Bhopi
40-60 ratios
instead of 80-20
40 factual, 60 descriptive type, personal response,
and writing section etc.
Prof
Ajay Undegaonkar
SSC Board has already removed oral test for 10th std.
from this academic year, same should be the pattern for 12th std.
Prof
Rajjak Shaikh
Good but too late
Prof
Trubhuvan Manisha
Sir don't u
think the time for paper is not sufficient because students have to read the
passage. They have writing skills etc.
Prof
Sayeed Saipan Saheb Solapure
Rajabahu mone jr college Goregaon
I think that oral exam should not be conducted for 12
class. Only 100 marks English paper should be design by the board based on
activity. No doubt oral exams are useful for passing the exam with flying
colours, but the drawback is the students are not at all serious and the
teachers also play the bias role by helping the students who are attending
tuition class students by telling them the spellings and sentences and answers
in the classroom, which is totally illegal to maintain quo status of education
thoroughly.
Thanking you in anticipation.
Prof
Dr. Santosh Ramnath Wagh, Nashik
Namaste sir I
think oral exam should not be important but we have to think both sides- rural
and urban student. In rural area there is not enough facility of tuition or private
coaching and in urban area students have got different sources notes of
English. Most of the student come from English medium; semi English so they can
easily solve the English que paper without oral exam but in village tribal area
they are unable to read the sentence even can’t write their own correct
spelling when they have to fill their HSC board form at that tm we have to
write the correct spelling of their regular subject; seat no on the blackboard
and this is a real fact at everywhere. And my own experience most of the time
due to marks of oral exam rural student speak 5 to 6 sentences; telling their
own information; trying to speak English though it is not grammatically correct
and I think oral exam is the source of confidence specially to urban; tribal
student so according to me oral exam should be continued for HSC
Prof.Manoj
Khaire
Yes I agree
with u sir. Oral exam is very important to boost confidence as well as enrich
the oral speaking ability of the student. Many rural students yet not understand
the new format of question paper or even not understand the simple practical
question on given passage. So result of 10th definitely decreasing.
Prof.
Ahirrao R. B. Shubhda college Malegaon
Yes it is
necessary to continue oral exam, keeping in mind the abilities of urban and
rural students.
Prof
P.M. Sambare
Oral exam and A,B,C,D
set are different if we think about
orals just ask ourselves why has the Board decided to cancel it? Why are we
against different sets, whatever the pattern is launched, some of our colleagues
are working there, they are always doing something for students improvement
Prof
C. A. Patil Navalnagar Dhule
Correct sir. (Agree with Prof P.M. Sambare’s views)
Prof
Sampat Kadam Latur
Is it apt to
have oral of 20, calligraphy of 20, communication of 20, Vernacular of 20, classical
of 10 and finally written of 10?
Jr.
College English Teachers’ Group 9
Prof
Annajigar Madhu
There is no need to have different sets because no two
extracts will have the same difficulty level. We are doing injustice to some
students. Some way or the other we can't be impartial. I don't really
understand what we want to prove by providing different sets.
Regarding oral exam, it should be a part of
evaluation. It has a great purpose to serve in this Era of enormous increase in
the mass media of communication. As science is incomplete without practical
examination, language without oral examination stands incomplete. If there is a
problem in the way in which the exam is conducted. A new system should be
introduced. Oral exam not only enables the students to get employment in future
but also prepares them to face interviews.
